The Whitby Witches | Chapter 3


‘I hate you!’ she stormed. ‘You’re nothing but a load of old witches!’ 

Aufwader’s Thoughts: Oh, ammonites! To choose a single, all-encompassing symbol for every Whitby book Mr Jarvis has ever written (or will ever write) is to choose the ammonite. That curling, many-segmented, ancient remnant of Britain’s prehistoric past has become deeply connected to everything that Robin’s Whitby is about, and they’ll turn up time and time again in the chapters ahead.

In this post I feel I absolutely must make passing reference to Paul Magrs’ Never the Bride, the first book of the ‘Brenda and Effie’ mysteries, which follows the Whitby-based paranormal escapades of a pair of meddling old dears who are themselves not all they seem. It was my love for The Whitby Witches which lead me to Never the Bride, and the subplot with Miss Boston and her friends which begins here is a perfect miniature  Brenda and Effie mystery.

The question which lurks gleefully in both this chapter and in Never the Bride is this: just what do elderly ladies get up to together over tea and scones? In Never the Bride, the reveal is that Brenda and Effie are illicit detectives of the paranormal; blue rinsed saviours of the human race. In this chapter, the reality of the secret doings of Miss Boston and her friends is that they really are witches, but unlike in Never the Bride, this revelation is only superficially humorous.

In trying to tap into Ben’s gifts, Miss Boston has betrayed the children’s trust and destroyed the good rapport they were beginning to have with her completely. In this, Ben and Jennet’s new guardian is revealed to be not a perfect, saintly grandmother figure, but a flawed human being (albeit one with supernatural powers) who sometimes misjudges situations and makes poor decisions. The relationship between her and the children must now begin to grow again from a basis of total honesty, and we hope it will grow stronger as a result.


Matt’s Thoughts: Is it just me, or does everybody love old British ladies? (Maybe it’s because I’ve been recently watching The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel and Judi Dench and Maggie Smith are in my mind.) But here we have a cast of the best old ladies, almost snatched from the pages of an Agatha Christie novel. (At first glance. Mr Jarvis has a lot more depth of character than that!)

But I love how each of them has a quickly definable quirk that makes them instantly distinguishable. Mrs Joyer’s military bearing. Tilly Droon’s dithering. (Mrs Banbury-Scott’s eating!) There is an undeniably comic side to the idea of the Ladies Circle.

By the same token, however, it’s utterly creepy for Ben! Again, I’m reminded of Danny Torrance wandering around The Overlook Hotel, seeing horrific sights than nobody else can hear.

One thing I was curious about was the fact that some ghosts appear relatively complete while others are a sort of grey mist. This does make me wonder: why is that? Is it an age thing – older ghosts are fading away with time? Or is there some sort of technicality in this limbo land that determines what level of presence spirits still have on this earth?

Final thing to note is that I believe (Aufwader will be sure to correct me if I’m wrong!) this chapter is the first mention we have of serpents / dragons in a Jarvis book. Sinister Reptilian Things is a motif that crops up from time to time in a few Jarvis books, which I’m sure we’ll speak more of in due course if you stick around with us on this blog long enough …


2 thoughts on “The Whitby Witches | Chapter 3

  1. One thing that’s a bit weird looking back on this book is how Mrs Banbury-Scott is singled out amongst the witches in an almost vitriolic way, with constant mentions of how unsightly fat and greedy she is. (I mean she was a rich toff too so) but that’s the sorta thing that I thiiink wouldn’t be encouraged nowadays without at least a side-eyeing.

    (I mean, the second book continues this when we get to the yobs in it, but that’s kinda not due yet).

    Liked by 1 person

  2. And here we have a chapter that dramatically shakes the boat! What a shocking revelation it ends on for poor Jennet!

    It must be said that, as dearly as we all love Aunt Alice, you really can’t feel too surprised when the girl freaks out on her. Ever since her parents were killed, every adult who entered her life has let her down cruelly. Then Alice Boston comes swooping in to rescue her and Jennet is so completely won over, trusting this new protector enough to let her guard down and admit things things she’s probably never spoken of to another soul. It’s only natural that she’s furious when it seems as though Aunt Alice only rescued the children from the system so that she could exploit Ben’s sixth sense. Who wouldn’t? It comes like a slap in the face after everything she’s already been put through, an unforgivable betrayal. As far as Jennet can see, she and her brother finally found someone who gave a damn about them and now she’s left feeling as if they were just being used.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s