The Whitby Child | Chapter 4


Warning: Contains Spoilers!

‘The Allpowerful does not “ask” – he demands.’

Aufwader’s Thoughts: Hillian is my favourite of the three (or rather, two-and-a-bit) antagonists who are introduced in this chapter, and I’ve always liked the little scene where she does her summoning on the shore.  On reread, it reminded me of Doctor Spittle’s necromancy magic in Chapter 6 of The Alychmist’s Cat – both scenes are momentous to the plot, but both have their grandeur tarnished somewhat when the everyday intrudes.

In Spittle’s case it was his relentless mumbling and Will’s long-suffering attitude which lightened proceedings. Here, it is a combination of Hillian’s utter failure to be adequately dressed for the Whitby weather and the fact that her ritual takes quite a while to bear fruit that makes the whole thing seem faintly ridiculous. Honestly, what’s the point of being the Almost High Priestess of the Black Sceptre if your good shoes get ruined in the wretched wet sand and your unholy invocation to the powers of the fathomless oceans takes so long to work that you have time for a smoke break?  A bit shoddy, I call that. A bit unprofessional.  Evidently, bringing a puny warlock back from the dead is not high on the agenda of the Deep Ones.

Speaking of Nathaniel, did anyone else groan and think ‘oh here we blooming well go’ when the Coven of the Black Sceptre was brought up? A glad day it was when Crozier suffered his agonising and well-deserved demise in A Warlock in Whitby, but it seems his witchy groupies aren’t likely to follow suit any time soon. As the last part of this chapter illustrates in gruesome detail, the new Whitby Witches are just as dangerous as their deceased leader. Despite the coven member’s botched assassination-by-ammonite, it looks as if Ben, and the rest of our heroes, may be facing their worst peril yet.


Matt’s Thoughts: Well, we’ve definitely got our villains now, as we meet yet another coven. In many ways, I find this to be the mirror image of Book 1. There we were introduced to a bunch of sweet old ladies who lived in Whitby who got together for witchcraft.

Here we have a sort of slightly younger, shop-working class of woman, who also get together for witchcraft on the side – but of a much darker, murkier type.

She only gets one chapter, but the character of Susannah O’Donnell is another fascinating Jarvis ‘grey’ character – yes, she’s part of the Crozier coven, but under different circumstances, might she have chosen a different path? (And we’ll never know now.)

Meanwhile, I love the idea of the fishmonkey barking orders. (And the inspiration for that particular character came from a fake mermaid that Robin found one day.)

I should also add – now that I’ve had a read of Robin’s Whitby Child page, that his inspiration for Sister Frances came from the comedienne Joyce Grenfell, but I must confess I’ve never seen any of her films. Anyone else?


7 thoughts on “The Whitby Child | Chapter 4

  1. The most terrifying thing about this chapter of course, was that it completely rendered moot the concept of all of Jarvis’ books being set in the same universe (well MOSTLY in the same universe, Deathscent and the Mooncaster trilogy are impossible to reconcile with the rest) but then in the illustration for the chapter, all three books of a certain mice trilogy are in the background…

    (Unless you pretend that they were real events translated by some author blessed with a milder version of the Sight…)


    • However, as I have recently alluded in the comments for Warlock, there *is* a line in the forthcoming Thomas which serves to suggest that the Deptford and Whitby books do indeed take place in the same universe…… 😉


      • You know, as I have read both Thomas AND the Whitby books, I dont remember any sort of direct link other than ‘evil serpents’…


    • The line in question comes from a passage discussing just how ancient the central evil of Thomas is, and goes as follows:

      “Whilst on western shores the foundations of the three thrones were still part of the living rock and the Raith Sidhe had not grown to an eighth of their later strength, in the East a foulness reigned.”

      The first half of this line, referring to “western shores” and the “three thrones” seems to be a pretty obvious allusion to the Lords of the Deep and Dark.


  2. Hats off to you, Drearily, for spotting the three Deptford books on the shelf. I didn’t notice that one at all! I must admit, I do like the idea of there being one ‘Jarvis universe’ even though, I’m pretty sure Robin himself told me on Twitter once that he didn’t necessarily plan them to be connected.

    But then again, he told me there was no particular reason for only having 14 chapters in his early books, when I had a much grander theory in my mind that 14 had a special significance.

    So I say let’s pursue the Jarvis Universe theories until they break! If we collectively come up with a really grand unifying theory that’s 100% brilliant, I’ll be happy to let Robin say he planned it that way all along.

    I also think I *can* reconcile the Mooncaster books, but I haven’t read Deathscent and Wyrd Museum yet, so they’re the ones I’m not sure about.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s